bhagolblog

Almanac · The gist

Amanta and purnimanta

Indian lunar months are cut in two different places, at the full moon in the north and at the no-moon night in the west and south, so the same festival night can carry two different month names without anybody being wrong.

This is the short way in. The essay has the working, the sources and the sky.

On the same Friday night this September, one family calls it the eighth day of Bhadrapada and another calls it the eighth day of Shravana. They are watching the same moon, keeping the same night, and eating at the same hour.

A lunar month is one full round of the moon's shapes. It takes about twenty-nine and a half days. A round has no natural starting point, so somebody has to choose where to cut it, and the moon gives two obvious places. One is the full moon. The other is the no-moon night, when nothing is showing.

North India cuts at the full moon. That system is called purnimanta, which means "ending at the full moon". Gujarat, Maharashtra and the states down the peninsula cut at the no-moon night. That system is called amanta, "ending at the new moon".

Every month has a bright half, when the moon is filling, and a dark half, when it is emptying. Because the two systems cut at opposite points, they take those halves in opposite order. This has one visible effect. During the bright half, both systems use the same month name. During the dark half, they differ by exactly one name, and the northern name is one month ahead.

So full moons are called the same thing everywhere. No-moon days are not. And any festival in a dark fortnight, such as Janmashtami, gets two month names and one date.

The rough north-and-south rule has exceptions. Gujarat is amanta and is not southern. Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Bengal, Assam and Odisha run their everyday calendars on solar months instead, so they are answering a different question. And the boundary has moved before: dated inscriptions show the northern system in use in parts of the south until about the ninth century.

Words decoded

panchang (पञ्चाङ्ग)
the printed Indian almanac sheet
tithi (तिथि)
a lunar day, measured by the moon's distance from the sun rather than by the clock
purnima (पूर्णिमा)
the full moon day
amavasya (अमावस्या)
the no-moon day
paksha (पक्ष)
a fortnight, either the filling half or the emptying half of the month
amanta (अमान्त)
the reckoning in which the month ends at the no-moon night
purnimanta (पूर्णिमान्त)
the reckoning in which the month ends at the full moon
Why anyone should careFamilies argue about this across phone lines every year, and the argument is about a word rather than a night. Once you know that the two systems only ever part during the dark fortnight, and always by exactly one month name, the disagreement stops being a disagreement.
Read it properly, 6 min Amanta and purnimanta