bhagolblog

Tradition · The gist

One thousand and thirty-one aphorisms

A second, quite different way of reading an Indian birth chart survives in a book so short and so tightly written that nobody can use it without a guide, and nobody agrees on who wrote it or when.

This is the short way in. The essay has the working, the sources and the sky.

The whole system arrives in 1,031 aphorisms. Many are three or four words long. One of the important ones is two words long. The entire text could be copied out by hand in a day.

Most Indian astrology follows one style, the one named after the sage Parashara. There is a second style, named after a Jaimini, and it is a genuinely different instrument. Its book is called the Jaimini Sutras.

A sutra is an aphorism: a rule squeezed into as few words as possible so a student could memorise the whole book. Sanskrit teaching texts were often built this way. The words were what you kept in your head; a teacher supplied the meaning. When the teachers were gone, other people wrote the meaning down, and those written explanations are called commentaries.

This book goes a step further than most. One of its own lines tells you that in many places you must not read the words for their sense at all. You read the letters, which stand for numbers, which stand for the twelve signs and the twelve houses of a chart. So a word meaning "good judgement" can simply be the number 144 in disguise. Someone who reads Sanskrit perfectly, with no key, gets nothing.

The idea the school is famous for is this. In the usual system each planet permanently stands for certain people: one always signifies the father, another the spouse. Here those roles are handed out fresh in every chart, depending on where the planets happen to fall. A planet carrying one role in your chart carries a different one in mine. Even the number of roles is argued over, seven or eight, and the argument is written into the old text itself.

Who wrote it, and when? Nobody knows. The name matches a famous philosopher, and the tradition treats them as one man. But the oldest dated copy anyone has found was written in 1729, and no earlier datable book seems to mention it, which points to a late date and a southern origin. A dated copy only tells you when somebody copied it, not when it was composed. So the question stays open.

Words decoded

sutra (सूत्र)
an aphorism; a rule compressed into a few words so it can be memorised
aphorism
a very short saying that packs a whole rule into as few words as possible
commentary
a later writer's explanation of a short text, usually far longer than the text
Jaimini Sutras
the short aphoristic book behind the second system of Indian chart reading
Parashara
the sage whose name is attached to the tradition's largest handbook, and to the mainstream system
karaka (कारक)
a planet treated as standing for a particular person or matter, such as a parent or a marriage
atmakaraka (आत्मकारक)
in this system, the planet that stands for the self in a given chart
naisargika karaka (नैसर्गिक कारक)
the older kind of significator, fixed by nature and the same in every chart
dasha (दशा)
a stretch of time an astrological system marks off, so a chart is read in stages rather than all at once
chara dasha (चरदशा)
the best known of this system's periods, counted in signs rather than in the years the common method uses
manuscript
a copy of a book written out by hand, before printing
critical edition
a printed edition made by comparing many handwritten copies and recording where they differ
Why anyone should carePeople are often told that Indian astrology is one settled body of knowledge handed down intact, and here is a book at the centre of one of its schools whose author is unknown, whose date is contested by centuries, part of which no old commentator explains, and whose arithmetic practitioners still disagree about. None of that obliges you to throw the tradition away; it does mean that when a rule is quoted at you with total confidence, you are entitled to ask where it comes from and who decided what it means.
Read it properly, 7 min One thousand and thirty-one aphorisms