bhagolblog

Inheritance · The gist

Asking to see your own chart

Asking your family to show you the birth chart they keep for you is a request to read, not a promise to believe, and the evening goes better if you can tell the document apart from the stories told over it.

This is the short way in. The essay has the working, the sources and the sky.

Three different texts turn up in the room that night: the paper, what the astrologer said out loud when he handed it over, and what the person who kept it remembers of that. Only the first one is written down, and it is often the one nobody in the family can read.

A request to see your own kundli is heard in at least three ways, and not one of them is the request you actually made. A kundli is the birth chart many Indian families have drawn up for a baby a few days old, kept somewhere careful and usually never read by the person it is about.

The words are easy. The fear is that the question will be heard as something else: as you giving in, as you saying you now believe what your family believes about it.

Here is how it lands. A parent may hear hope, because they have wanted you to take an interest for years. A parent may hear alarm, because in many houses the chart only comes out when something has gone wrong, so asking sounds like a warning that something is wrong with you. A relative further away may hear victory in an old family argument. None of that is what you meant, and nobody is being unfair. They are reading you with the only information they have.

So put your meaning inside the sentence: I want to read what you have kept. Then stop. Do not add "but I don't believe in it". That sentence gives the room an argument to have instead of a document to fetch, and it tells the person holding the paper that you think they are foolish.

Watch out for the request growing. You asked to see a document; what comes back can be an appointment with the family astrologer. Say early and gently that you want to read the paper, not sit through a reading.

When the chart appears, it comes with a narrator. Ask, calmly, whether each thing you are told is written on the page or remembered from what the astrologer said years ago. Both are worth having. Mixing them is what causes trouble.

Do not argue with the paper in front of the person who kept it; that argument will not sound like it is about paper. Write down that night what you saw and what you were told. Say thank you, and mean it.

Words decoded

kundli (कुंडली)
the birth chart a family has drawn up for a new baby, a diagram of where the sun, the moon and the planets stood at the moment and place of the birth, usually with tables beside it
astrologer
the person who worked out that chart and wrote it, in many families somebody the household has used for two or three generations
a sitting, or a reading
a session where an astrologer talks you through a chart and answers questions; different from simply looking at the document
Modi script (मोडी)
a fast handwriting used for Marathi in offices and businesses from the 13th century until about 1950, when the standard Devanagari style replaced it; old family papers are often written in it
Devanagari
the everyday script used to write Hindi, Marathi and Sanskrit today
keeper
the person in the house who actually holds the document, often a mother, a father or a grandparent
Why anyone should carePlenty of people want to read the one document their family made about them and never ask, because they think asking commits them to a belief. It does not. Being able to look at something without taking a side on it is a useful adult skill, and this is a low-cost place to practise it, with somebody who loves you sitting on the other side of the table.
Read it properly, 7 min Asking to see your own chart